SharePoint Document Issues

Fix SharePoint Designer 2010 Workflow Failing to Create an Item in the Same List

Jason MillerJason Miller Nov 13, 2026 868 views

Question details

Determine why a SharePoint Designer 2010 workflow cannot create a new item in the list that triggered it.

Fix a SharePoint Designer 2010 Workflow That Cannot Create an Item in the Same List
Product
SharePoint Designer 2010 workflows
Device & OS
not provided
Scenario
An automatically triggered workflow creates an item in its current list after evaluating date conditions and generating a title.
Observed behavior
The workflow fails to create an item in its triggering list, while another workflow can create items in a different list.
Before you start

Identify the affected list, the failed workflow instance, and a working workflow to use for comparison. Check whether the workflow runs in SharePoint Online or an on-premises environment; SharePoint 2010 workflows have been retired in SharePoint Online.

Solution 1Recommended

Check the Workflow History and Item-Creation Configuration

Use the failing workflow's history and action settings to identify the specific field, condition, or configuration causing the failure.

There is no general restriction that prevents an automatically triggered SharePoint Designer 2010 workflow from creating an item in its current list. A workflow that succeeds in another list may have different required fields, validation rules, permissions, or action settings.

1
Inspect the failed instance

In the affected SharePoint list, open the item's workflow status or Workflows menu, select the failed workflow instance, and review its history for the failing step and error message.

2
Check the target list and fields

Open the workflow in SharePoint Designer, edit the Create List Item action, and confirm that it targets the intended list. Check the selected content type and provide valid values for all required fields, including any required lookup fields.

3
Compare list settings

Open List Settings for both the affected list and the list used by the working workflow. Compare required columns, content types, unique-value settings, and validation rules that could reject the new item.

4
Test a simple creation action

In SharePoint Designer, test a simplified version of the workflow with a Create List Item action that supplies valid values for required fields. Publish it and trigger it on a test item.

5
Add the logic back

If the simple test succeeds, add the date conditions and title expression back one at a time in the workflow editor, publishing and testing after each change. Check that the generated title and dates meet the list's field and validation requirements.

Check the Workflow History and Item-Creation Configuration
Review the trigger: Check the workflow's start options before testing. Creating or changing items in the same list may cause additional workflow runs depending on the trigger configuration.
Free Microsoft Office alternative

Work With SharePoint List Exports in WPS Office

WPS Office is a free, lightweight alternative for reviewing and editing office files with a familiar interface. Open supported Microsoft Office files and move existing documents into WPS with minimal disruption. It does not repair SharePoint workflows.

Review exported list data in WPS SpreadsheetsCompatible with Microsoft Excel XLS and XLSX filesFamiliar spreadsheet interface for working with existing filesFree and lightweight for everyday office tasks
microsoft office alternative - wps office

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a SharePoint Designer 2010 workflow create an item in the list that triggered it?

Yes. There is no general restriction against creating an item in the same list. If the action fails, inspect the workflow history and check the target list's fields, validation rules, and permissions.

Why does a workflow work in one list but fail in another?

The lists may have different required columns, content types, lookup requirements, validation rules, unique-value settings, or permissions. Compare them under List Settings and inspect the Create List Item action in SharePoint Designer.

Which permission should I check for creating a list item?

Check that the identity used by the workflow action has Add Items permission on the target list. Open List Settings > Permissions for this list and use Check Permissions where available.

Could the generated title or date prevent the item from being created?

Yes. A title or date can be rejected if it does not meet a required field, unique-value setting, or validation rule. Test the Create List Item action with simple valid values, then add the title and date logic back one step at a time.

Are SharePoint 2010 workflows still supported in SharePoint Online?

No. SharePoint 2010 workflows have been retired in SharePoint Online. If the workflow is in SharePoint Online, plan a migration to a supported automation solution; availability in an on-premises environment depends on its SharePoint version and support status.