Office for Mac Issues

Fix Grayed-Out Comments and Notes in Excel for Mac

Steve KSteve K Nov 20, 2026 868 views

Question details

The user needs to make the Comments and Notes commands available in Excel for Mac.

Fix Grayed-Out Comments and Notes in Excel for Mac
Product
Microsoft Excel for Mac
Device & OS
macOS
Scenario
The user wants to add a comment or note to a cell in an Excel workbook.
Observed behavior
Insert Comment and Notes commands may be grayed out even though the workbook is not protected or shared.
Before you start

Select a worksheet cell and press Esc to exit cell-editing mode, then check the commands on the Review tab. Note the workbook's file extension and whether the issue also occurs in a new workbook.

Solution 1Recommended

Check the workbook format and test a new workbook

Use this check to determine whether the issue is limited to an older file or affects Excel more broadly.

Older formats such as .xls, .xlm, and .xlt do not support the newer threaded Comments feature. Notes are different from threaded comments, so an older format alone may not explain why Notes is unavailable.

1
Test a new workbook

Choose File > New Workbook, select a cell, and check the Comments and Notes commands on the Review tab.

2
Check the file type

Open the affected workbook and check its extension in Finder or in the File > Save As dialog.

3
Try a modern format

For a suitable workbook, choose File > Save As and save a copy as an Excel Workbook (.xlsx). Reopen the copy and check the commands on the Review tab.

Check the workbook format and test a new workbook
Check for macros: The .xlsx format cannot retain VBA macros. If the workbook contains macros, consider a macro-enabled format such as .xlsm instead.
Free Microsoft Office alternative

Work with Excel files in WPS Office for Mac

WPS Office is a free, lightweight alternative with a familiar spreadsheet interface and support for common Excel formats, making it easy to move existing files. It does not repair the grayed-out commands in Microsoft Excel.

Open and edit spreadsheets in a familiar interfaceCompatible with common Microsoft Excel formats, including .xlsx and .xlsAdd cell comments while reviewing spreadsheet dataMove existing spreadsheets into a lightweight Office suite
microsoft office alternative - wps office

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is Insert Comment grayed out in an older Excel file?

Older formats such as .xls do not support newer threaded comments. Try File > Save As and save a suitable copy as .xlsx, then reopen it and check the Review tab.

Are comments and notes the same thing in Excel?

No. Newer comments support threaded conversations, while notes are the older style of cell annotation. A format limitation affecting threaded comments does not necessarily explain a grayed-out Notes command.

How can I tell whether the problem affects every workbook?

Choose File > New Workbook, select a cell, and check Comments and Notes on the Review tab. If they work there, investigate the original workbook's format and settings.

How do I update Excel on my Mac?

In Excel, choose Help > Check for Updates. If Excel was installed from the Mac App Store, open the App Store and check Updates.