Fix SharePoint List Save Buttons That Handle Validation Differently
Question details
The user needs both SharePoint list Save buttons to show a validation message when an entry violates a rule.

- Product
- Microsoft SharePoint Lists
- Device & OS
- not provided
- Scenario
- A SharePoint list form has a validation rule applied to the Title column and offers two Save buttons.
- Observed behavior
- The form-level Save button displays the validation error, but the top Save button closes the form without saving or showing the message.
Open the affected list and identify the validation formula and message currently configured for the Title column. Note any other column validation rules so you can account for them when testing changes.
Move the validation rule to SharePoint list settings
Use list-level validation as a workaround when the two Save buttons handle a column-level rule differently.
In the affected SharePoint list, open Settings > List settings, select the Title column, and note its validation formula and user message.
Return to List settings and select Validation settings.
Enter the formula in the Formula box and a helpful error in the User message box. For example, use =[Title]<>"1" to reject a Title value of 1, then select Save.
Open the Title column settings, remove the equivalent column-level validation rule, and save the change. Create or edit an item with an invalid Title and try each Save button; then test a valid value.

Compare browsers and gather evidence for Microsoft support
Use this approach if list-level validation is not practical or the behavior continues.
Work with Office files in WPS Office
WPS Office is a free, lightweight Office alternative with a familiar interface and Microsoft Office format compatibility for an easier transition. It does not change SharePoint list validation or fix SharePoint Save buttons.

Frequently Asked Questions
Where do I configure list-level validation in SharePoint?
Open the affected list, go to Settings > List settings, and select Validation settings. Enter the formula and the message users should see, then select Save.
How can I test whether both Save buttons show the error?
Create or edit a list item with a value that violates the rule. Try the form-level Save button and the top Save button separately, then repeat with a valid value to confirm it saves.
Can I keep separate messages for several rules in list validation?
List-level validation provides one formula and one user message. Compatible conditions can sometimes be combined, but the shared message should explain the requirements users need to meet.
What should I do if the workaround does not resolve the issue?
Test in another browser and with another user, record the formula and results, and capture a video if possible. Ask your Microsoft 365 administrator to contact Microsoft through Help & support in the admin center.




