Security Policy Errors

Why Microsoft 365 Delivers Phishing Emails to the Inbox

Elise WilliamsElise Williams Nov 3, 2026 868 views

Question details

The user needs to understand why identical spear-phishing messages have inconsistent delivery outcomes across different recipients in Microsoft 365 and how to investigate the filtering decisions.

Why Microsoft 365 Delivers Some Phishing Emails to the Inbox
Product
Microsoft 365 Defender
Device & OS
not provided
Scenario
Managing organizational email security and investigating spear-phishing attacks where threat actors constantly change IP addresses.
Observed behavior
Some phishing emails bypass security policies and reach the user inbox, while identical messages sent to other recipients are quarantined or blocked as spam.
Before you start

Ensure you have administrator access to the Microsoft 365 Defender portal and the Exchange admin center to run message traces and analyze email headers.

Solution 1Recommended

Analyze Complete Message Headers to Compare Filtering Decisions

Comparing the email headers from a recipient who received the phishing email and one who had it blocked will reveal why Microsoft 365 classified them differently.

Inconsistent delivery often occurs because Microsoft 365 Defender relies on real-time threat intelligence. If attackers rapidly change sending IP addresses, the initial emails might bypass filters before the system identifies the pattern and blocks subsequent messages.

1
Identify affected recipients

Locate two recipients of the identical phishing campaign: one who received the email in their inbox, and another where the email was successfully quarantined or routed to the junk folder.

2
Extract the message headers

Instruct both users to extract the complete internet message headers. In Outlook, open the message, click File > Properties, and copy the text in the 'Internet headers' box. Alternatively, administrators can retrieve this data via the Exchange admin center using Message Trace.

3
Analyze the authentication and SCL scores

Paste the headers into a tool like the Microsoft Remote Connectivity Analyzer. Compare the Spam Confidence Level (SCL) scores, Bulk Complaint Level (BCL), and authentication results (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) between the two headers.

4
Identify the discrepancy

Look for differences in the routing paths, timestamps, or IP addresses. A timestamp difference often explains why a later email was blocked once Defender updated its threat intelligence regarding the new IP address.

Analyze Complete Message Headers to Compare Filtering Decisions
Privacy Precaution: When sharing message headers with IT support or community forums for assistance, always redact sensitive organizational information or use private messaging to protect your privacy.
Free Microsoft Office alternative

Experience a Secure and Lightweight Office Suite with WPS Office

While Microsoft 365 handles complex enterprise email routing and security, your team still needs a reliable, secure, and fast office suite for daily document tasks. WPS Office provides high compatibility with Microsoft Word, Excel, and PowerPoint files without the heavy resource usage, making it an excellent free alternative for secure document editing.

  1. 1. Download WPS Office: Visit the official WPS website and download the free installation package.
  2. 2. Install the Software: Run the installer and follow the simple on-screen prompts to set up WPS Office on your computer.
  3. 3. Open Microsoft Formats: Launch WPS Office to immediately open, edit, and securely save your existing Word, Excel, and PowerPoint documents.
Built-in document security and encryption to keep sensitive files safe from local threats, complementing your organization's email security.High compatibility with Microsoft Office formats (.docx, .xlsx, .pptx) ensuring zero formatting loss.Lightweight installation with exceptionally fast document loading speeds.Familiar user interface requiring zero learning curve for a seamless migration.
microsoft office alternative - wps office

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does Microsoft 365 Defender allow some phishing emails through initially?

Defender evaluates emails using real-time threat intelligence. If an attacker frequently changes their sending IP addresses or domains, the very first batch of emails might bypass filters because the reputation score hasn't dropped yet. Once the system identifies the suspicious pattern, subsequent messages are blocked.

How do I find the message header in Outlook on the web?

Open the email in Outlook on the web, click the three dots (More actions) in the top-right corner of the message, select 'View', and then click 'View message details'. This will display the full internet headers.

What does a Spam Confidence Level (SCL) mean in my email headers?

The SCL is a rating assigned to incoming emails by Microsoft 365 Exchange Online Protection. It typically ranges from -1 (bypassed spam filtering) to 9 (high confidence spam). Comparing the SCL scores across identical emails helps administrators identify why routing decisions differed.