How to Fix Missing Reply-To Address for Microsoft 365 Public Folders
Question details
The user is unable to set or locate the Reply-To address configuration for migrated public folders within a Microsoft 365 hybrid Exchange setup.

- Product
- Microsoft 365 Exchange
- Device & OS
- not provided
- Scenario
- Managing and configuring email routing for migrated public folders after transitioning between Microsoft 365 Groups and public folders.
- Observed behavior
- The Reply-To address setting is missing or fails to apply, preventing correct return paths for emails sent from the public folder.
Ensure you have the necessary Exchange Administrator permissions and that your PowerShell session is actively connected to your Exchange Online environment.
Set the Primary SMTP Address via Exchange Management Shell
Use PowerShell to bypass graphical interface glitches and directly assign the primary Reply-To address while checking for specific backend errors.
In hybrid environments, the Exchange Admin Center may occasionally fail to display configuration fields correctly. Using PowerShell allows you to directly enforce the primary SMTP address, which acts as the Reply-To address.
Launch the Exchange Management Shell as an administrator or connect your local PowerShell session to Exchange Online.
Ensure that the email address policy is disabled for the target public folder, as an active policy may override your manual configuration.
Run the following command, replacing <address> with the actual public folder identity and desired email address: Set-MailPublicFolder -Identity <address> -PrimarySmtpAddress <address>
Check the PowerShell console for any red error text. If the command succeeds silently, the Reply-To address has been successfully updated.

Change the Default SMTP Address in the Exchange Admin Center
Use the web-based Exchange Admin Center (EAC) to designate an existing email address as the default reply address.
Enhance Your Daily Productivity with WPS Office
While resolving Exchange Server administrative issues requires Microsoft 365 backend tools, your daily document management and email correspondence do not have to rely on expensive software. WPS Office is a free, robust suite tailored for all your essential productivity needs.

Frequently Asked Questions
Why is the Reply-To address option grayed out in the Exchange Admin Center?
This typically occurs when the 'Automatically update email addresses based on the email address policy applied to this recipient' option is enabled. You must uncheck this setting in the public folder's properties before you can manually edit the Primary SMTP or Reply-To address.
Can a public folder have multiple Reply-To addresses?
No. While a mail-enabled public folder can have multiple proxy addresses to receive mail, it can only have one Primary SMTP address, which dictates the default Reply-To address for outgoing or automated responses.
How do I check if my public folder is mail-enabled?
You can verify this by checking the Exchange Admin Center under the 'Public folders' section to see if it lists an email address, or by running the Get-MailPublicFolder cmdlet in Exchange Online PowerShell. If it returns the folder details, it is mail-enabled.




