Email Recovery

How to Separate Merged PST Data in a Microsoft 365 Mailbox

Tauseeq MagsiTauseeq Magsi Oct 22, 2026 869 views

Question details

The user needs to separate messages after accidentally importing one user's PST file into another user's Microsoft 365 mailbox.

How to Separate Merged PST Data in a Microsoft 365 Mailbox
Product
Microsoft 365
Device & OS
not provided
Scenario
Managing mailbox data after an accidental PST import synchronizes with Outlook on the web.
Observed behavior
The imported PST data merges with the existing mailbox data and the action cannot be automatically undone.
Before you start

Ensure you create a complete backup of the current merged mailbox and have the original PST file available for reference before attempting any data separation.

Solution 1Recommended

Filter and Export Data Using the Original PST File

Use the original imported PST file as a reference to identify the incorrectly merged messages and move them out manually.

Because an accidental PST import cannot simply be undone once synced with Microsoft 365, you must manually isolate the incorrectly added items. By referencing the original PST, you can identify specific parameters to locate the merged data.

1
Open Outlook and analyze the original PST

Access the mailbox where the PST was accidentally imported. Review the original PST file to determine specific dates, sender names, or unique folders associated with the imported data.

2
Search and isolate the merged emails

Use the Outlook search bar to filter emails based on the criteria you identified. Select the matching emails and move them to a newly created folder named 'Separated Data'.

3
Export the isolated data

Go to File > Open & Export > Import/Export. Choose 'Export to a file', select 'Outlook Data File (.pst)', and export the 'Separated Data' folder to a new, isolated PST file on your local drive.

4
Verify and delete

Open the newly exported PST file in Outlook to ensure all data is intact. Once verified, you can safely delete the separated messages from the current user's mailbox.

Filter and Export Data Using the Original PST File
Imperfect Separation: Manual and automatic separation methods may not be perfect. Always retain backups of your mailbox before permanently deleting any filtered data.
Free Microsoft Office alternative

Try WPS Office for a Lightweight Document Management Alternative

Dealing with complex Microsoft 365 data issues can be frustrating. For your daily document, spreadsheet, and presentation needs, WPS Office offers a highly compatible, free, and lightweight alternative to Microsoft Office.

  1. 1. Visit the official website: Go to the official WPS Office website to find the correct version for your operating system.
  2. 2. Download the installer: Click the Free Download button to get the lightweight installation file.
  3. 3. Install and launch: Run the installer, follow the simple on-screen instructions, and launch WPS Office to open your documents immediately.
Fully compatible with Microsoft Word, Excel, and PowerPoint formats.Lightweight installation that won't slow down your computer.Familiar user interface makes switching from Microsoft Office seamless.Built-in PDF editing tools for comprehensive document management.
microsoft office alternative - wps office

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I click 'undo' after importing a PST file in Outlook?

No, once a PST file is imported and synchronized with Outlook on the web or Microsoft 365, the action cannot be directly undone with a simple click. You will need to manually separate the data.

Will Outlook rules help separate the merged mailbox?

Yes, you can create custom Outlook rules based on specific senders, recipients, or date ranges found in the original PST to automatically move these emails into a dedicated folder. However, you will still need to manually review the sorted items for accuracy.

Is it safe to delete the emails once I filter them out?

You should only delete the filtered emails after you have successfully exported them to a new PST file and verified that the original mailbox owner's data was not accidentally included in the batch.

Can I use the Import/Export wizard to remove the merged data?

The Import/Export wizard can only add data (import) or save data to a file (export). It does not feature a tool to 'remove imported data', meaning you must rely on manual filtering and exporting to isolate the merged files.